Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

Lori McKiernan speaks to the Zoning and Land Use Committee on Nov. 19. Credit: PHOTO BY DILPREET RAJU

More than two dozen Sangamon County residents attended the Zoning and Land Use Committee’s Nov. 19 meeting, with public commenters critiquing the data center code approved by the committee last spring for lacking protections and asking committee members to consider a moratorium on data centers.

The meeting came the same day top economists warned of the U.S. economyโ€™s reliance on technology stocks and Anthropic became the first artificial intelligence lab to launch an initial public offering on the U.S. stock market, and just three days after Illinois regulators released a study that proposes delaying the end dates for 11 gas and oil plants across the state to spring 2033, largely to fulfill data center electricity demand.

Don Hanrahan, an environmental advocate and member of the Coalition for Springfieldโ€™s Utility Future, pointed out how all local Illinois ballot measures related to data centers showed little support for the massive server warehouses during the November election. He also criticized the countyโ€™s existing data center code, which was approved by the Sangamon County Board last July โ€“ five months after CyrusOne officials scheduled a March meeting with County zoning staff, according to emails obtained through FOIA by the Coalition for Springfieldโ€™s Utility Future.

โ€œCyrusOne and SSGA (Springfield Sangamon Growth Alliance) and certain county officials knew of CyrusOneโ€™s plans weeks before they came here and proposed a zoning ordinance for you guys to approve โ€“ they decided they wanted it, they drafted an ordinance, they presented it to you, they greenlit the project with it, they announced the project and now theyโ€™re spending money defending that one and recruiting more. People donโ€™t want these things,โ€ Hanrahan said.

โ€œWe don’t even require more than a cursory environmental review under our current regulation. We don’t have a decommissioning plan under our current regulation โ€“ there are big holes in it that have to be fixed,โ€ he said. โ€œThe board chairโ€™s assurance that no new permits have been applied for doesnโ€™t mean heโ€™s unaware of any new proposed data centers that heโ€™s been relentlessly recruiting with our tax dollars.”

RELATED

Lori McKiernan, another member of the Coalition for Springfieldโ€™s Utility Future who encouraged people to attend the meeting, said it’s a bad idea to court data centers at a time when stock and bond markets are in active recoil around AI investments and whether theyโ€™ll provide worthy return on lofty investments.

โ€œThe Growth Alliance and whoever is on the County Board who think that it’s a good idea to be calling data centers are seriously misguided,โ€ she said. โ€œA moratorium would allow time for this AI bubble scenario to play out, so we don’t have multiple empty data centers when the bubble burstsโ€ฆ this committee should begin the process for a data center moratorium at the next meeting. It would be irresponsible of you to delay proposing a data center moratorium.โ€

Erin Kirkpatrick, a Sierra Club volunteer who regularly attends community meetings, asked committee members to consider the idea of a data center proposed in their district.

โ€œI would ask all of you to imagine the next data center being proposed in your district. I would ask you to take a look at the current zoning and ask if that is something you would accept being in your district. Imagine what all of your constituents would come to you and say about all of that being applied to where you live or put yourself in the position of somebody who’s going to be 300 yards away from the next data center,โ€ she said.

โ€œThereโ€™s a lot of things that we have been trying to rush into for the name of prosperity,โ€ said Javon Ware, a Sangamon County resident who expressed concerns for his childโ€™s future.

Gary Schulze, who lives about a mile from the site approved for the CyrusOne data center in Talkington Township, called District 7 where he lives a โ€œsacrifice zone.โ€

โ€œMost decisions seem to be made from face value,โ€ Schulze said, noting that he believes County Board members cannot also represent the Growth Alliance’s agenda. โ€œI believe that if you are a member of SSGA or County Board, it’s one or the other, not bothโ€ฆ it would also be great if the public could ask questions and get answers, and not at staged conventions. I did not approve SSGA using my tax dollars to promote half-told truths on Facebook (advertisements) and TV commercials.โ€


Concerns span the country, state

On Thursday, the Chicago Federal Reserve president warned of AI-related inflation and Anna Wong, Bloombergโ€™s chief U.S. economist, wrote that โ€œtechnological leadership and booming AI demand arenโ€™t translating into durable pricing powerโ€ฆ Anthropicโ€™s IPO could look less like the start of another leg of the AI trade, and more like one last burst of fuel.โ€

Meanwhile, the Illinois Power Agency, Illinois Commerce Commission and Illinois Environmental Protection Agency jointly released the stateโ€™s resource adequacy study (required by the Climate and Equitable Jobs Act) that proposes delaying the phaseout date for 11 gas and oil plants across the state to 2033 in order to fulfill the electricity demands of data centers. The phrase โ€œdata centerโ€ appears nearly 130 times in the almost 230 page report.

Screenshot: Mitigation Plan, Illinois Power Association, Illinois Commerce Commission, Illinois Environmental Protection Agency.

โ€œProjecting data center load is subject to considerable uncertainty. Publicly available information on the size, location and timing of proposed data center projects is sparse,โ€ the report states. โ€œCapacity additions and increased imports more than offset retirements, suspensions and reduced accreditation, although MISO (Midcontinent Independent System Operator) continues to identify the need for additional resource development as load growth driven by data centers accelerates.โ€

The report illustrated concerns about MISOโ€™s ability to reliably source enough power to avoid a shortfall for its Illinois region, which spans the central and southern regions of the state.

Screenshot: Mitigation Plan, Illinois Power Association, Illinois Commerce Commission, Illinois Environmental Protection Agency.

โ€œThe shortfall risk reflects several related but distinct drivers. Growing electricity demand, primarily from data centers, increases capacity requirements. Separately, aging and economically marginal generators may retire across PJM and MISO. The updated load and resource balance indicates tight regional capacity conditions which creates a risk of shortfalls if sufficient resources do not enter service on time,โ€ the resource adequacy report states. MISOโ€™s Illinois region โ€œhas less in-zone accredited capacity than its requirement in 2027 and must increasingly rely on imports; sufficient unused capacity may not be available elsewhere in MISO to support those imports during stressed conditions.โ€

Regulators contend keeping the 11 gas and oil plants, mostly in northern Illinois, running would be the most risk-averse method to handling the projected increase in electricity demand as renewable buildouts would simply not come online fast enough.

The report, which was released during the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference, also writes that coal plants โ€œgenerally produce substantially more (greenhouse gases),โ€ which is why IPA, ICC and IEPA โ€œsupport preserving the reliability contribution of gas and oil while maintaining the decarbonization timeline applicable to coal units.

โ€œRetaining existing, already-interconnected units, especially gas and oil, also directly reduces loss-of-load risk and eases a resource buildout that would otherwise have to occur at more than three times Illinoisโ€™ historical annual pace of resource additions,โ€ the report states.


Dilpreet Raju is a staff writer for Illinois Times and a Report for America corps member. He has a bachelor's degree in biochemistry from American University, a master's degree from Medill School of Journalism...

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *