Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

Standing with one of the dogs available for adoption at the Sangamon County Animal Control Center, county health department director John Ridley and Jeanne Keenan, the center's director of operations, say the center isn't perfect but doesn't deserve the criticism it has received from Springfield alderperson Roy Williams Jr. Credit: Dean Olsen

Springfield isn’t getting its money’s worth from the city’s contract with Sangamon County for animal control services, especially when it comes to a lack of timely responses to complaints about stray and vicious dogs and a proliferation of groundhogs, according to Ward 3 Ald. Roy Williams Jr.

“There are tons of citizens who will tell you about the bad service,” Williams told Illinois Times in advance of an hour-long public hearing on the topic scheduled for 5 p.m. Nov. 30 in Lincoln Library’s Carnegie Room North. “I want to know what Animal Control does. What are we paying for?

“The enforcement piece is missing,” Williams said. “When people let their dogs loose at night or let them roam … rarely is there a penalty. … They just take too long to come.”

Williams’ ward, which covers parts of the city’s east and north sides, accounted for 25% of the more than 2,400 annual calls for service – the largest share of any ward, during the city fiscal year ending in February. Ward 3 was followed by Ward 2, which accounted for almost 22%.

Williams’ criticisms of the Sangamon County Animal Control & Adoption Center during weekly council meetings and media interviews in recent months and years drew rebukes from county officials who said they have a cooperative relationship with most other representatives of the city.

“He doesn’t know what he’s talking about,” said John Ridley, director of the Sangamon County Department of Public Health, who oversees the Animal Control center.

The frequency and broad swath of his critiques of Animal Control make Williams unique among Springfield City Council members.

Ridley said, “He just shoots from the hip and gets people all riled up for nothing.”

The center’s operations aren’t perfect, Ridley said. “But we don’t need to take these criticisms that are unfounded – that make us look like we’re not doing our job – because they’re the ones that have the microphone every Tuesday night, not us,” he said.

Jeanne Keenan, the center’s director of operations, agreed and said unfounded and broad accusations “demoralize our animal control officers, because they watch the City Council meetings. … It’s not helpful.”

Ridley added that the county doesn’t have the resources or the staff to trap and remove groundhogs, raccoons, opossums and other wildlife in people’s yards. And he disputed statements by Williams and Ward 2 Ald. Shawn Gregory that the east side is “infested” with groundhogs and that there are more groundhogs in Springfield neighborhoods than in the past.

Gregory said at a council meeting in October that groundhogs “are really, really starting to take over our city, just like cats and dogs.” 

And Ridley said that contrary to Williams’ statements, Animal Control officers aren’t avoiding seizing stray or aggressive dogs for fear of further overloading the animal shelter, which is often near capacity or full. 

Ridley also contradicted Williams’ statement that the shelter has a “no-kill” policy.

The shelter has space to house 95 dogs and 80 or more cats and can handle more when abandoned litters of puppies or kittens are dumped on the sides of roads or found in houses. The shelter admits about 4,600 animals per year and tries to arrange for adoptions of as many as possible, Ridley said, adding that the euthanasia rate is 9%.


John Ridley, director of the Sangamon County Department of Public Health, and Jeanne Keenan, director of operations for the county’s Animal Control & Adoption Center, are pictured standing outside the center at 2100 Shale St. in Springfield. They defended the center amid  allegations of poor service from Springfield Ward 3 Ald. Roy Williams Jr. Photo by Dean Olsen.

Council to discuss payments, contract

What Williams described as years of his constituents voicing dissatisfaction with enforcement of the city’s animal control enforcement laws is intensifying ahead of the informational session by city and county officials and the expected renewal of the city’s animal control contract with the county. 

The increased tension also comes as the City Council and mayoral election approaches on April 6 and as the county, which bills for services after they have been provided, requests a $615,000 payment for services rendered from March 1, 2025, through Feb. 28, 2026.

The reimbursement requested would be a more than $76,000 increase – 14% more – compared with the previous year’s payment. The increase, Ridley said, was related to “an increase in calls and all associated activities with those calls.”

If approved in the weeks following the Nov. 30 info session, county officials hope to kick off a new payment system in which the city is billed quarterly rather than annually.

Ridley, who has directed the health department for three years, and Keenan, who has led Animal Control for almost four years, refuted Williams’ claims of slow responses and lax enforcement, though Williams said individual complaints shouldn’t be minimized and Ridley agreed.

Information from the county that Ridley said was presented to the City Council earlier this year for calls in 2025 showed an average response time of 38 minutes to respond to reports of stray dogs or cats – the most common complaint. The response time represents the time from when the call was received to when an Animal Control officer is on the way to the scene.

Other commonly reported calls and their average response times included about two hours for a complaint related to negligent care of an animal and an hour and 12 minutes for a dead racoon or other type of wildlife.

The city of Springfield represents 95% of all of the calls handled by Animal Control officers, whose duties include enforcement of city ordinances dealing with animals, Ridley said.

Williams said the complaints he receives from constituents indicate improvements are needed, regardless of the data on call responses.


Ward 3 Ald. Roy Williams Jr., shown in his office next door to his home on Springfield’s east side, says he and his constituents have been dissatisfied with the Sangamon County Animal Control Center’s response to complaints about stray and vicious dogs and wildlife such as groundhogs. Photo by Zach Adams.

County versus city control

Operations of the Animal Control center at 2100 Shale St. in Springfield, which includes five enforcement officers, total about $2 million in spending each year. That’s a relatively small amount for a county government with a $206 million annual budget.

But Ridley said he spends a lot of time focused on the 18-employee center because of the importance of animal welfare to county residents and because the county’s response to vicious and stray animals is more tangible than many functions of county government.

Indeed, pets can be as common, or more common, than children in homes.

Thirty-nine percent of American households include a child younger than 18, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. That compares with 43.7% of U.S. households with a dog and 34.1% with a cat, according to the American Veterinary Medical Foundation.

Williams, who worries that the county is taking over too many services in Springfield that used to be the responsibility of city government, has suggested that the city consider hiring its own animal control officers so city residents receive more attention.

The city eliminated its animal control unit in 2000. A November 2000 story in The State Journal-Register quoted a city official at the time as saying the decision to pay the county to handle that job was to “eliminate confusion and save money.”

That was about the time Sangamon County moved into what was then a new animal shelter on Shale Street to replace a 25-year-old building at 2801 N. Fifth St., near the Illinois State Fairgrounds.

The city and county in 2006 agreed to merge the city and county health departments into a single entity operated by the county.

Partly in response to Williams’ criticisms, the city in November 2025 issued a request for bids for animal control and shelter services but received no proposals.

“The city is always open to exploring available options to ensure we are providing the best possible services at the lowest cost for the taxpayers,” city spokesperson Amanda Brown said.  

Williams said he wonders whether the political challenges of starting up such a service for the city have intimidated other organizations.

Williams, a Democrat on the officially nonpartisan City Council, said Buscher, a Republican in the officially nonpartisan position, isn’t aggressive enough in holding the county accountable on animal control services because of the Republican Party’s control of all countywide elected offices and the County Board.

“In the meantime, our people suffer,” Williams said at the Oct. 20 City Council meeting. He told Buscher, “Your friends get to keep the contract and make the money and provide no service.”

Williams also said, in an interview with Illinois Times, “This goes across race. This goes across party lines. In my ward, they don’t feel like they have any service anyway.”

Buscher told IT that she isn’t overlooking any problems at Animal Control because of politics. She noted that Williams was “having a fit” about Animal Control when her predecessor, Democrat Jim Langfelder, was mayor.

“Personally, I believe Ald. Williams makes everything political and not about policy,” Buscher said. “It isn’t about me or a political party; it’s about services and community. And that’s really how I operate as a mayor.”

Buscher said the county’s animal control center is “doing very well. Those of us that provide services to the constituents have a limited amount of money. … I believe that they’re working within their budget and they’re doing everything they can to serve the constituents of not just Springfield but Sangamon County.”

Buscher said she believes that Springfield would have to spend more to start up its own animal control services than what the city currently pays the county for animal control.

“I have not had a giant issue with their services,” she said. “I can understand if a constituent felt something took too long or wasn’t happy with the services. That does happen when you’re a public servant. Everything isn’t perfect all the time, unfortunately.”

Leland Grove resident Jill Egizii, the volunteer president of Springfield-based WILD Canine Rescue, a foster-based rescue organization focusing on dogs, defended Animal Control’s operations under Keenan. 

Egizii said it’s a vast improvement since the county’s firing of Greg Largent as Animal Control director in 2022 following an internal review of operations and social-media allegations of mistreatment of animals.

The State Journal-Register reported that Gail O’Neill, the county health department’s director at the time, cited Largent’s inability to lead a unionized workforce as a factor in his dismissal. O’Neill said an investigation by Illinois State Police and the Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation failed to find evidence of animal abuse or neglect.

Egizii said Keenan, who previously was an environmental health support supervisor in the county health department, is “doing a really, really good job over there.”

Before Keenan took charge, Egizii said, “The responses were slow, if any. There was no direction or leadership there.” 

Keenan has reinvigorated the ranks of volunteers who work with animals at the shelter. And as for the current level of enforcement, Egizii said, “Can they get to every call right away? You’re covering a very large area. … I think they’re really, really trying hard.”

 Egizii, a former board member for the Friends of Sangamon County Animal Control, said Animal Control officers are doing “the best job they can possibly do” when so many people are abandoning former pets because of the increasing costs of care and a proliferation of backyard breeders in Springfield that result in many unwanted animals.

Regarding Williams’ critiques of the center’s operations, Egizii said, “Roy likes to create drama.”


Addressing underlying issues

Keenan said the best way to reduce the city’s animal control contract cost is to work with the county to reduce the number of animal intakes. That can happen, she said, by promoting spay and neutering of pets, reducing backyard breeding and promoting responsible pet ownership – all challenging tasks.

Ridley said he and Keenan would like to see the city adopt the ordinance proposed by Ward 8 Ald. Erin Conley in 2024 to give the city official information about the number of backyard breeders of animals, mainly dogs.

Conley, who said she dropped her proposal because of lack of interest among her fellow council members at the time, told IT more recently that she is interested in reviving the discussion before her term as a council member is up in the spring.

Her original proposal called for a $100-per-year registration fee for breeders of one or more animals, though she said she would be willing to reduce or eliminate the fee. Breeders violating the ordinance could be cited and face potential fines of $100 to $500.

Former County Board member Marc Ayers, Illinois state director for Humane World for Animals, has endorsed the concept to put backyard breeders “on notice” that there is some oversight and pave the way for future regulations and educational efforts to encourage responsible conduct.

The Animal Control center is “crawling out of a hole financially,” Ridley said.

It used to operate with a deficit of $1 million, requiring county government to cover 50% of the center’s costs not funded by fines and fees such as animal licenses, he said.

Ridley said the deficit has been reduced by half in the past three years, in part through better follow-through by Animal Control, working with Springfield police and the Sangamon County State’s Attorney’s Office, to collect fines. 

Other cost-control efforts have helped, as well, he said, allowing Animal Control to budget for a potential sixth animal control officer in the county fiscal year that begins Dec. 1.

Ridley said Williams hasn’t taken Ridley up on his offer to visit the shelter and discuss the alderman’s concerns one by one. Williams said he doesn’t like Ridley’s attitude and considers Ridley a promoter of his own resume.


Residents speak out

Williams said his own constituents’ complaints can’t be denied. 

* Celinda Hearn, 71, who lives on Williams’ block, said she called Animal Control several times this year to complain that a neighbor was letting his pit bull run in the neighborhood and she was concerned for her safety.

Hearn, a retired state worker, said Animal Control officers came to the neighborhood in response to her calls. But each time, she said, they told her that they decided not to fine the dog owner and give him another chance and not seize the dog. 

Hearn said she called Animal Control later and was told pit bulls weren’t being picked up because the shelter was overcrowded. The dog owner and his dog later moved after a fire damaged their house.

Hearn also said she was frustrated that Animal Control wouldn’t help her trap a groundhog on her property. “I don’t feel like we’re getting the help that we need,” she said.

* Ernest Coleman, 65, a Ward 3 resident and retired Sangamon Mass Transit District driver, said he, too, would like Animal Control to trap and remove groundhogs. He said he and his 81-year-old mother, who lives nearby, are having problems with groundhogs digging up their yards and can’t afford to hire exterminators.

* James Chappell, 81, a retired state worker who lives on 25th Street, said Animal Control officers used to trap and remove the feral cats, opossums, raccoons and other small animals attracted by a next-door neighbor who leaves out cat food for the cats.

Chappell said he would like Animal Control to resume trapping and removal of these animals. “It’s really a nuisance,” he said.

* Angelle Phelan, 25, of the 1200 block of West Ash Street, lives in Ward 8. She said she has complained several times to Animal Control about a neighbor who has two roosters, along with numerous chicken and geese. She said Springfield police have cited the neighbor for violating the city’s noise ordinance because of the roosters crowing and she wants Animal Control to cite the neighbor for owning roosters within city limits. However, current city ordinance does not address the issue.  

When informed of the complaints, Ridley said he will reach out to the residents individually to resolve their concerns.

“Most of the discussion between those four people relate to dealing with wildlife,” he said. “We do not trap wildlife for individuals. There are circumstances where we will assist with wildlife calls, for example, a bat in a house. If there is wildlife in a living area of a dwelling, we will assist with that. But we will not go into attics or crawl spaces to trap animals.

“I plan on completely covering the topic of wildlife in the Nov. 30 public presentation.”

Williams said he will examine the new contract with Animal Control that Buscher presents in the coming weeks and may propose amendments to improve services in his ward. 

“I want them to do better,” he said.


Dean Olsen is a senior staff writer with Illinois Times. He can be reached at dolsen@illinoistimes.com, 217-679-7810 or www.x.DeanOlsenIT.

Dean Olsen is a senior staff writer for Illinois Times. He can be reached at: dolsen@illinoistimes.com, 217-679-7810 or @DeanOlsenIT.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *