Fifty years after its Broadway premiere, Annie returns to Springfield for the holiday season. With its memorable tunes, old-fashioned comedy and overwhelming “aww” factor, it’s no wonder The Legacy Theatre chose to stage the classic now.
“We wanted to do an authentic production for the 50th anniversary. The show takes place during Christmas, and we wanted to make it a gift for the community,” said director Laura Mitchelle. That idea proved to be well-timed, as Broadway recently announced a revival of Annie slated for fall 2027 – a move that will restrict local licensing. This may be the only time to see Annie ’round these parts for a long while.
For those who never belted “Maybe” out a bedroom window, praying Daddy Warbucks would arrive to fund a Limited Too shopping spree, here’s the gist: set at Christmas in Depression-era New York, Annie follows a group of plucky orphans and a lot of adults making questionable choices. Tough-yet-nurturing 11-year-old Annie holds onto the hope that her parents will return, until she unexpectedly lands at the Fifth Avenue estate of billionaire Oliver Warbucks for a holiday PR stunt.
Rich Beans plays Warbucks to perfection. In lesser hands, the role can skew dictatorial or downright creepy, but Beans’ genuine warmth shines from the start. Paired with gorgeous vocals, he is everything an audience could hope for in a Daddy Warbucks.
Warbucks isn’t the only scene-stealer – if there’s one thing Springfield audiences love, it’s kids in the arts and a homeless dog, and Annie delivers both. In fact, it has two groups of kids (and unfortunately only one dog). Rather than relegating some of the girls to understudy duties, Mitchelle double-cast the orphans into two teams, titled red and blue, that alternate performances every other night.
Chrissy Mauck, who plays Grace Farrell true to the character’s namesake, praised how the theater prepared its young cast.
“The Legacy set things up so well,” Mauck said. “They had these orphan boot camps for all of the girls, and got through all of their stuff very early on in the rehearsal process. They’re all such stars.”
That early prep pays off onstage. The orphan cast features Kadence Haynes, Jane Holzmacher, Brinley Lobb, Georgia Mitchelle, Mary Iris Selinger and Nylah Stimage on the Red Team and Corinne Brooks, Emmy Craven, Livy Craven, Annie Croke, Isla Kohlrus and Magdalena Osterhuber on the Blue Team. Both ensembles deliver tight vocals and impressive stage presences wrapped up in spunky, small packages.
There is only one Annie, though, sung beautifully by Rose Lyman in her Legacy debut. Lyman belts out each tune in a pitch-perfect straight tone that sounds as though someone walked into the room and hit play on a Broadway cast recording. Even when a few adults needed line reminders during final dress rehearsal, Lyman never faltered, staying right on cue while wrangling her four-legged co-star, Sandy (played by Pippa). It’s an impressive feat for such a young performer. Pippa held her own, too – though unlike Lyman, she was rewarded with treats for the bare minimum of stage time.

Lori Ann McCabe shines again as the drunken, surly orphanage madam, Miss Hannigan. Her banter with the orphans feels genuinely playful, as if everyone knows they’re free to ham it up. When a button snagged on an orphan’s dress during rehearsal, the ever-professional McCabe yelled in character, “You dang dress-rippin’ orphan, now everyone will see my bra!”
Broderick Elder brings slimy charisma to Miss Hannigan’s villainous brother, Rooster, a con man who may or may not have a problem murdering orphans. Though a Legacy veteran, this is Elder’s first show with a large cast of kids.
“The energy is ramped up all the time,” Elder said. “There’s a lot more chaos, but it’s fun chaos.”
Alongside him, Grace Hughes delivers one of the funniest Lily St. Regis performances imaginable, pairing a hilariously ditzy blonde act with squeaky-voiced charm.
A standout that also must be mentioned is the “Star-to-Be” soloist, Lydia Ressler, who belts out her “N.Y.C.” feature sounding and looking like a true star already. She was fantastic.
The Legacy’s Annie is pure holiday comfort food. It’s heartwarming, family-friendly and doles out a much-needed dose of festive nostalgia. This show is a wonderful reminder that optimism is always in style and you’re never fully dressed without a little Christmas spirit.
Annie, directed by Laura Mitchelle and produced by Scott Richardson, continues its run at the Legacy Theatre Nov. 20- Jan. 9. Performances start at 7 p.m. Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday and 2 p.m. Sunday. Tickets and cast information are available at atthelegacy.com

I always savor reading Courtney Wick’s pithy and fresh reviews. Kudos for seizing the perfect opportunity to use the word “plucky!”