Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

Illinois Times compiled SPD's annual traffic stop reports for 2019 through 2025 and collated the data into a spreadsheet that can be accessed at illinoistimes.com. Credit: CREDIT: ADOBE STOCK PHOTO

The Springfield Police Department launched a “transparency page” in August that relays crime statistics, but questions have arisen about why certain information is – or isn’t – included.

The SPD’s page does not include the number of cases closed by police or state-mandated transparency reports. While SPD’s own documents also initially stated quarterly audit data would be included on a public transparency page, those materials have not been posted on the portal and SPD now says it’s not required.

Mayor Misty Buscher hailed the portal at the time of its release, saying the city could be more “productive” by relying on well-sourced data, and SPD Chief Joseph Behl said more data will be “extremely eye-opening for the community.”

However, advocacy groups, Springfield City Council members and Illinois Times have questioned why the transparency page doesn’t include information about traffic stops by race, which has been a hot-button issue for SPD and other police departments nationwide. According to data from the Illinois Department of Transportation, 48.5% of Springfield drivers stopped in 2025 were Black, although Black people only represent around 17% of the city’s population. Black drivers were five times more likely to be stopped by SPD than white drivers.

Behl said the traffic stop tab of SPD’s transparency page is imported with a different management system than the data that SPD is legally required to submit to the IDOT for the state’s annual Traffic and Pedestrian Stop Study. He also gave an example, to both City Council and IT, of a time he stopped someone for driving erratically but did not note the driver’s race.

“(T)here was somebody upset with me that we don’t put race on all these tabs. We don’t put it on there because it’s not available,” Behl said during a Sept. 3 interview with IT.

“I made a traffic stop some time ago; when I made that stop, I ran a young lady(’s information) over the radio – just checked to make sure her driver’s license was valid. Never once was there a race discussed, so that traffic stop is logged but the race isn’t there,” Behl told the City Council Oct. 20.

Amanda Brown, director of communications for the city, responded to a series of inquiries IT emailed to Behl, SPD communications liaison Nikki Monari and other high-ranking SPD personnel over the course of two months that went unanswered. Behl also declined a face-to-face request for an interview by Illinois Times. Brown said Behl’s example “appears to have been misunderstood.”

She wrote: “Traffic stops are logged by Sangamon County Combined Dispatch dispatchers when officers call them out over the radio. When officers run an individual through law enforcement databases, the individual’s race is not communicated to the dispatcher because it is not a required data point for that inquiry. The Illinois uniform traffic citation does not contain a demographic identity for race.

“Dispatch logs this information in the computer-aided dispatch system, which automatically populates into the records management system (RMS). Race data is not included in this process, as it is not a part of the uniform traffic citation… (t)he stop sheet is sent to IDOT as a part of the traffic study; it is not sent to the city’s law enforcement databases and those data points are not logged into RMS.”

Since 2004, police departments across the state have been legally required to submit information for the study that strictly delineates traffic stops by race, reason for stop, outcome of stop and any search procedures. One of the first paragraphs of state law governing these studies clearly states that whenever a police officer “issues a uniform traffic citation” or warning citation, the reporting officer will record “the name, address, gender and the officer’s subjective determination of the race of the person stopped.”

That means SPD is essentially submitting duplicate information to the state and to its own databases whenever an officer conducts a traffic stop, but less information is sent back to SPD.

Although SPD’s transparency page now includes a link to the state’s traffic study page, interested individuals would have to seek out a given police department’s report from separate annual documents spanning thousands of pages.

Illinois Times compiled SPD’s annual traffic stop reports for 2019 through 2025 and collated the data into a spreadsheet for anyone to peruse.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Illinois notes traffic stop data is one way to assess policing in practice. The national ACLU has said traffic stops, especially “non-safety” related stops, result in more uses of force – particularly against Black people – and rarely turn up illegal contraband.

Ed Yohnka, director of communications and public policy for ACLU of Illinois, told Illinois Times that SPD should be posting as much information as it can about the types of traffic stops its officers make, especially if police officers want to gain trust among marginalized communities.

“Including the additional information about race and the reason for stops in the (transparency) dashboard would be instructive for local residents, especially residents who have expressed concern about racial bias in stops in Springfield for a number of years,” Yohnka wrote. “But simply posting a web page is not enough. Community members deserve a dialogue with police – in Springfield and every community – about how police analyze data around enforcement strategies such as traffic stops. How are stops for minor infractions – for a light bulb that is out, for example – part of a strategy for public safety? How do police feel when they see disparities by race in the number of people stopped for traffic stops or asked for consent searches? These are issues deserving of a larger, public conversation where police can hear from the community – a conversation far more helpful than posting data on a website.”

SPD officials have denied a pattern of racial bias in traffic stops, but last year agreed to implement some changes following discussions with representatives from the Springfield chapter of the ACLU. Officers are now required to document their reasons for requesting to search a car for contraband following a stop, and grant money was used to fund a new program that helps motorists fix safety equipment on their cars to help avoid stops for broken taillights or other minor issues.


Business and civilian camera audits

An SPD general order stating quarterly audit data for civilian camera usage would be required to be posted on the department’s public transparency page was later changed to omit that requirement and backdated to Sept. 2, the day prior to Behl’s meeting with an IT reporter. The day after the meeting, Illinois Times emailed Behl and Monari asking about the general order contradicting Behl’s statement from early September.

The language in SPD’s OPS-93 accountability section was then updated to remove the phrase “for release on the departments (sic) web-based transparency portal.”

IT sent repeated follow-ups to Behl and spokespersons for SPD but has not received responses from any of those individuals since the Sept. 3 meeting.

At that time, Behl told IT that SPD did not produce quarterly written reports for camera use data but would do so if there was a concern to address.

“We don’t have any files generated, necessarily. If there’s an occurrence or an issue with something, we would generate a file. We’ve not had any of those,” Behl said Sept. 3.

During staff meetings, “(w)hether it’s some kind of equipment or program or software or hardware or whatever, they just give us a report back and it’s just a verbal report, ‘Hey, this is what’s going on.’ If there is an issue with it, then there would be pen to paper and then we’d be like, ‘OK, yeah, well, we need to investigate that, figure out what’s going on, are they using this appropriately, or are they not?’”

Illinois Times sent a Nov. 17 follow-up email asking why the change to the general order was made, why it was dated Sept. 2 and filed a Freedom of Information Act request seeking internal communications.


Dilpreet Raju is a staff writer for Illinois Times and a Report for America corps member. He has a bachelor's degree in biochemistry from American University, a master's degree from Medill School of Journalism...

Join the Conversation

1 Comment

  1. “Black drivers were five times more likely to be stopped by SPD than white drivers.”

    They’re also 13% of the population yet 50% of the murderers. Whoops

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *