Solid Play falls short of delivering a knock-out
Those who read my reviews on a regular basis are aware that my No. 1 complaint regarding movies these days is that they are too long. While the overall running time is an issue for many of the bloated productions coming out of Tinsel Town, a greater concern is how that time is used. I’ve come to expect that I’ll check my watch multiple times during a movie as it spins its narrative wheels. So, imagine my surprise when I was left wanting more, in all the wrong ways, after seeing one of the most-highly anticipated films of the holiday season.
The franchise that made Sylvester Stallone a household name has come full circle with Peter Farrelly’s I Play Rocky, a compelling look at the actor’s struggles to get the seminal love story to the big screen. Propelled by an incredible performance by relative newcomer Anthony Ippolito and the intriguing behind-the-scenes machinations that went into its making, the movie accomplishes what the Best-Picture winner did when it debuted in late 1976. It too gives us a relatable, sympathetic underdog that we wind up cheering on against the odds, one whose struggles we can’t help but identify with. Farrelly replicates the feel-good tone of Rocky, the audience in the palm of his hand. That is, until its abrupt ending, one that leaves us longing to see our hero bask in his triumph, a moment the director inexplicably fails to include.
Stallone (Ippolito) is nothing if not tenacious. We see him pounding the grimy streets of New York City, circa 1974, living in a fleabag hotel, doing what he can to find acting gigs. He hits rock bottom, sleeping on the streets but eventually gets a job as a movie theater usher where he meets fellow ticket-taker Sasha (a great AnnaSophia Robb). He doesn’t realize how fortuitous this is, as she will wind up being the one person who believes in him when no one else does.
Writer Peter Gamble has the unenviable task of condensing nearly three years into a two-hour screenplay and does an admirable job. The main players and key events of Stallone’s rags-to-riches tale are all present and the film has a quick sense of pace that keeps us hooked. But in the end, many of them come off as underdeveloped. Early on, Stallone takes Sasha to meet his father Frank (an underused Matt Dillon), a cluelessly abusive man who takes every opportunity to deride his son. This is obviously a key catalyst pushing our hero to succeed but not nearly enough is done to mine that relationship, later scenes between the two lacking the impact they should as a result.
Upon moving to California, the film briskly introduces producers Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell) and Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne), who are taken with Stallone’s script, yet are advised by senior money man Sandy Maddox (Tracy Letts) to not let him star in the movie. Their ever-increasing offers to simply buy the script provide some unexpected humor and effectively underscore the actor’s determination. Director John Avildsen (Jay Duplass) is brought on board once production begins, leading to the casting of Carl Weathers (Stephan James), who has just as much to prove as Stallone. Like the actor’s father, these parts are also underwritten and we’re left wanting to know more about what makes them tick.
Even those with simply a passing interest in Rocky will appreciate the behind-the-scenes look at its making, the movie’s success a miracle of timing, luck and tenacity. We learn that Stallone was set up to fail by Wexler, the reason why the film was shot in Philadelphia, why cutting-edge technology was used to give it a distinctive look and how two iconic scenes, which were both done on the fly, were born. Equally fascinating is how we learn about elements from Stallone’s life – his less-than-posh digs, habit of drinking raw eggs, makeshift workout routines in the park and how he found his dog Butkus, are incorporated into Rocky.
Essentially, Farrelly is following the playbook that has kept this franchise going for 50 years – he’s simply remaking the original film, albeit through the lens of “reality.” There’s no denying it works as we feel Stallone’s pain, frustration and hope but are denied sharing in his triumph. The ending of the movie is cruel, robbing the viewer of the vicarious experience of celebrating with our hero. The conclusion is startling abrupt and while we all know how the story ends, seeing this version of Stallone/Rocky be vindicated is necessary to Play’s success. This omission is a major miscalculation that nearly taints the entire film.
Sitting through all of the credits is suggested as Farrelly utilizes archival footage to show us the aftermath of Stallone’s cinematic triumph. It’s a delightful look back at the actor and his wife, grounding the film and providing a sense of closure. To be sure, Play gives us all we’d expect from a movie of this sort, up to a point. Yet, stopping short as it does, the director fails to deliver the emotional knock-out punch we’ve come to expect and which the story deserves. In Theaters.
Monster a portrait of denial
Daring and compelling, Marie Kreutzer’s Gentle Monster tackles an issue unique to the 21st century, a scourge that shows no signs of slowing. Featuring Lea Seydoux, giving one of the best performances of the year, the film looks at the people who are on the periphery of the modern child pornography epidemic. Unflinching in its examination of the ripple effect of this act, the movie is a layered narrative, one that shifts in its perspective as its main character’s understanding of the nightmare that surrounds her deepens.
French citizens Lucy and Philip (Seydoux and Laurence Rupp), she a musician, he a filmmaker, have an unconventional lifestyle. Having moved to the German countryside to get a fresh start, as he ran afoul of the law for dealing drugs, they’re raising their 9-year-old son while pursuing their own projects. This is all turned upside down when the police show up on their doorstep one morning to confiscate Philip’s computer and a copious number of thumb drives. He is then arrested for distributing child pornography.
Blindsided, Lucy immediately leaves the home with her son, retreating to her mother’s (Catherine Deneuve) to regroup. On her heels, she’s grasping at straws, seeking answers. Philip claims to be innocent; she believes him. But as more facts emerge and her husband’s story continually changes, she begins to have her doubts.
Kreutzer creates an ever-growing sense of dread throughout. Key bits of information are revealed in an almost matter-of-fact way, each revelation contributing to the slowly unfolding nightmare Lucy finds herself in. It would be easy to brush the character aside as foolish and pathetic, but in Seydoux’s capable hands, our sympathies stay with the character throughout. Telling her mother, “You don’t simply stop loving someone,” when her loyalty to her husband is questioned, the victimization of Lucy occurs on many fronts, the writer/director doing a masterful job of putting a spotlight on those who are often collateral damage to this crime.
As a mirror to her troubles, the film also spends considerable time looking at one of the police officers assigned to Philip’s case. Elsa (Jella Haase) never admits it but we are led to assume she’s perhaps been a victim of sexual abuse. Her dementia-afflicted father (Sylvester Goth) exhibits tendencies that suggest this, while the impassive way in which she deals with Lucy and others speak to past trauma. It’s an intriguing approach, the drama in the interactions between the two characters stemming from what’s unsaid as much as what’s vocalized.
Ultimately, the movie reveals itself to be an examination of manipulation and denial, not simply about how we are victimized by those who lie to us, but how we can unwittingly do the same. That Lucy holds onto the notion that Philip is innocent is not simply an act of wishful thinking but is due to multiple factors, some of which she may not fully understand. As such, we come away hesitant to judge all Lucy does and doesn’t do. Her actions as a mother are above reproach; as a woman and wife, her confusion is understandable.
Lucy’s art involves reimagining contemporary love songs written by men. She states in an interview, “Men rarely talk about their feelings. I take their words and question them.” The ironic nature of this pursuit is obvious, as are many of the titles of the songs she deconstructs. In the end, Gentle casts its heroine as a woman who thinks she’s protecting herself, only to discover too late that she has a fatal blind spot. Streaming on Netflix.
Madden a joyous celebration of the man
Obviously, I never knew John Madden but I can’t help but think he’d approve of David O. Russell’s Madden, a high-energy, off-beat biopic that wonderfully captures his charming sense of irreverence. Fun, energetic and at times breathlessly entertaining, the film is nothing if not ambitious in its scope, covering the latter part of its titular subject’s coaching career, his time as a broadcaster and the birth of the video game bearing his name. If the movie has a fault, it’s that it attempts too much, glossing over key events. Yet it captures the essence of Madden’s philosophy toward life, the result being a joyful look at facing any and all challenges with optimism and strength.
We’re made aware of the movie’s tone from the get go with the disclaimer, “Not all of this happened. But most of this happened.” Letting us know he might be coloring outside the lines at times Russell immediately plunges us into the turmoil that is Madden’s (Nicolas Cage) life in 1976. Having never won a championship as the coach of the Oakland Raiders, the pressure is on for him to get it done in the AFC Championship game. However, that’s not his only concern. His long-suffering wife, Virginia (Kathryn Hahn), is demanding he spend more time at home, owner Al Davis (Christian Bale) is constantly pushing him for more and he’s developing some serious health issues. Life is more than just football, yet this is a belief Madden has never adhered to.
In a sense, the film is his journey toward embracing that simple notion, something that comes far too late in his life. We see him so consumed with football that he’s not able to accurately guess his sons’ ages and, after his retirement from coaching, begin to talk to his dog about the game when he’s left alone. What emerges is a portrait of a kind-hearted man with an extreme case of tunnel-vision, one so narrow he ends up alienating his family, reasoning that his passion for football is what gives him purpose and provides for his loved ones. That Davis is the devil on his shoulder constantly reiterating this doesn’t help.
His salvation comes in the form of broadcasting, with perhaps the most entertaining section of the movie covering his becoming a household name via his unique perspective on the game. Watching him put his rough debut behind him and develop into a broadcasting legend is a delight, his manic play-diagraming, distinctive sound monikers and promotion of the turducken, all covered with a manic sense of glee that you can’t help smiling at.
Equally intriguing is the development of the Madden Football game, spearheaded by the head of EA Games, Trip Hawkins (John Mulaney). Watching the coach educate the team of programmers about football so their game would be more realistic is a hoot, as is Madden’s growing appreciation of their skill set. The mutual admiration that develops between them is unexpected yet the film is able to draw connections regarding the tenacity they all share.
While Cage doesn’t look like Madden, he perfectly captures the character’s physicality and vocal patterns. The actor disappears in the role and instead of giving us a caricature of the man, underscores his humanity instead. Not surprisingly, Bale is just as good, his portrayal of Davis surprisingly sympathetic. It’s obvious these two screen vets are feeding off each other and their great work is what drives Madden into the end zone. When all is said and done, you won’t care whether all of what we see happened or not as it captures the essence of the man in all his glory.
This article appears in November 12-18, 2026.
