Andrea McLaughlin has occasionally had thoughts of dropping the “Seafood” from her store’s name and just going with “Robert’s Market,” because much more than just seafood is for sale in the fourth-generation Springfield store.
There is a full selection of beef from locally-sourced farms, not to mention 35 different kinds of olive oil and vinaigrette, fresh vegetables and a solid selection of wines, whiskeys and beer.
But, McLaughlin concedes, why do an expensive rebrand to one already so well-known in the area?
“People would probably be like, ‘Oh no, did you sell the business?’” said McLaughlin. She and her father, Robbie Robert, keep a business that was founded in 1916 on East Washington Street by her great-grandfather, Henry, in family hands.
Seafood is the store’s true bread-and-butter – both of which are also for sale inside the store at 1615 W. Jefferson St. – and new varieties are flown in fresh four days a week. Most supermarkets have some fresh seafood to choose from, but not to the depth and breadth of Robert’s.
Odds are you won’t find wild, fresh skate wing like you can at Robert’s, not to mention wild-caught walleye or swordfish steaks from Brazil. Yes, those items can put a dent in the wallet (the wild-caught walleye was $29.99 a pound during a recent visit), but the business has survived for 110 years for a reason. The product is high-quality and hard to find otherwise, and the foot traffic is always strong.
Robert’s Seafood Market was more of a wholesale business for many years. It was the first Midwest wholesaler of Birdseye foods, for instance, but for the last 20 years or so has become just one, independent store again.
“We don’t have any desire to build out a lot of stores elsewhere,” McLaughlin says. “This place keeps us plenty busy enough.”
This article appears in October 29-November 4, 2026.
