Hard times at Goodwill

Charity lays off folks it should help

click to enlarge Nicholas Braun wants his job back. - PHOTO BRUCE RUSHTON
Photo Bruce Rushton
Nicholas Braun wants his job back.
UPDATE: After the below story was posted online, Land of Lincoln Goodwill Industries reversed itself and has announced that Nicholas Braun and other former employees who lost their jobs this month will be rehired.

In a written statement issued Wednesday afternoon, Sharon Durbin, the agency's president and chief executive officer apologized for firing Braun and about a dozen of his coworkers. Durbin had blamed the layoffs on an upcoming increase in the minimum wage and had said that Braun's work and others who were let go often had to be redone by employees without disabilities.

"Our recent decision regarding the voc rehab program and the resulting harm it might have caused falls short of living up to our mission and we apologize for the error in judgment," Durbin said in the emailed statement. "We are reversing the decision to realign our voc rehab program and those participants affected will return to their part time skills training program with pay. As the leader of this organization, some challenges can be overwhelming to the point where the numbers, rather than those we are working to elevate, become the focus. Their challenges and their needs are personally near and dear to my heart. As the president and CEO of this organization, I want to apologize to our constituents, our clients and our faithful donors."

More than three hours after the statement was issued, Loni Braun, Nicholas' mother, said that no one from Goodwill has contacted her, but she's happy to hear the news. "It's what I wanted," Loni Braun said. "I'm thrilled. To be honest with you, I'm still very upset with Sharon Durbin."

Braun said that she hasn't spoken with her son, who is staying with his grandmother in Edwardsville.

The layoffs touched off a firestorm after the media began reporting on the layoffs last week. State Sen. Andy Manar, D-Bunker Hill, has called for the state to review all contracts granting public money to Goodwill.

The below column, posted earlier today, also will appear in this week's print edition.



Life’s too short to look like a homeless person. That’s why I shop at Goodwill.

Norwegian split-toe bluchers by Alden. Shell cordovan. Ben Silver button-downs, Brioni trousers and oxford cloth from Brooks Brothers. Spend enough time shopping at Goodwill and you can look better than the president, which these days isn’t saying much.

I didn’t know him until last week, but Nicholas Braun helped. They let him on the sales floor, occasionally, to put stuff back on hangers that shoppers hadn’t returned on their own. Mostly, he stayed in the backroom, finding mates for shoes amid heaped masses or pulling clothes from bins and hanging them on racks. Occasionally, he’d find a soiled diaper or discover a treasure – he says he once found $1,000 in a box that he turned over to a supervisor. Mostly, though, Nicholas plugged away, tossing anything stained into the do-not-sell pile, inspecting LPs for scratches and making sure that Barbra Streisand records weren’t in Madonna sleeves, or vice versa.

He loved his job – it’s the only one he’s had since graduating from high school. At 28, he lives with his mother near Divernon. For more than six years, Goodwill sent a van to pick Nicholas up each morning, and a van brought him home from work each afternoon. He earned $600 every month and called in sick twice.

It is, exactly, what Goodwill is supposed to do.

“Friends of Goodwill, be dissatisfied with your work until every handicapped and unfortunate person in your community has an opportunity to develop to his fullest usefulness and enjoy a maximum of abundant living,” Rev. Edgar Helms, the organization’s long-dead founder, once said.

Goodwill fired Nicholas, and more than a dozen coworkers, on July 1. Not enough money to pay you, the charity said in a June 14 letter that his mother says she received a week later. The last day was heavy. “We cried,” Nicholas recalls. “We were like family.” Some who lost their jobs, he says, live in group homes.

Nicholas isn’t like most people. For one thing, he turns on a zillion-watt grin in a nanosecond. For another, he was born premature and has been diagnosed with autism, Tourette Syndrome and a mild form of cerebral palsy. After high school, Nicholas studied at Lincoln Land Community College but wasn’t happy there. Goodwill was different. There is something to getting paid for working at a job most folks wouldn’t want and earning enough to buy junk food and clothes, for which Nicholas acknowledges weak spots.

Nicholas, still, is welcome at Goodwill, except he doesn’t get paid, nor does he do anything useful. Instead of hanging clothes and sorting shoes, he’s gotten perfect scores on worksheets that ask the sum of five-plus-three, part of a program in which Nicholas is supposed to learn life skills but which he finds too easy. Every morning, a van will still pick him up and deliver him back home in afternoons, but Nicholas says that he’s stopped taking the short bus. He wants a job.

Sharon Durbin, president and chief executive officer of Land Of Lincoln Goodwill Industries, says Nicholas and others were let go because Goodwill, faced with increases in the state’s minimum wage scheduled to start next year, can’t afford to pay them. “If anyone has a complaint about the changes we’re making, reach out to your legislators,” Durbin says. “The business model that Goodwill has had for many years isn’t going to work as we go forward.” She also says that Nicholas and his coworkers weren’t terrific, that others had to re-do their tasks and that Goodwill kept them on the payroll nonetheless. She talks about the future: If folks like Nicholas earn too much now, the feds might reduce benefits in later years.


These sound like excuses. Land of Lincoln Goodwill Industries has a history that invites one to wonder whether the agency has forgotten why it exists. Durbin’s predecessor resigned in 2005 after prosecutors gave him a choice: Quit or go on trial for Medicaid fraud. He was accused of falsifying documents to collect money that the charity didn’t deserve. Stores were staffed with temporary workers instead of employees. Finances were precarious. And the board of directors, which included judges, the county sheriff and other civic leaders, was oblivious. All they saw was paperwork that was just so much paper, showing that sales were steaming along when, in fact, the charity was amok.

Durbin has been credited with turning things around, and she’s been rewarded. She started out at $85,000 a year in 2006 and now makes $165,000. She’s hired her son to oversee retail operations -- he’s paid more than $95,000 while Nicholas never got a raise. Goodwill last week opened a Clinton store at a former Walmart. Given what’s happened to Nicholas, it’s fair to ask whether Goodwill has morphed into a chain of big-box stores that doesn’t pay taxes as opposed to a charity that has the disadvantaged as its primary concern.

I’m hearing, as I write this, that Goodwill might rehire Nicholas and others. In any event, Nicholas, thanks for the shoes. I appreciate it.

Comments (0)

Add a comment

Add a Comment
  • Al Kitchen

    @ Route 66 Motorheads Bar, Grill and Museum

    Mon., Dec. 9, 6-9 p.m.